Correction: The second phase of voting to narrow down the top six picks will be based on the comments section and the poll will be the tie breaker.
The border rivalry goes way back between Nanuet and Pearl River. There are a lot of good pizza places in both towns and Pearl River Patch editor Ryan Buncher and I want to know which one you think is the top pick among the non-chain places.
Here's how it works:
Vote in the Poll and explain your vote in the comments section below. We'll take these until 5 p.m. on Wednesday.
On Thursday morning, we'll post the top six picks and a poll. Post your vote in the comment section and vote in the poll as well. In the event of a tie in comments, the poll results will be used as a tie breaker. We'll take votes until 5 p.m. on Friday, and the winner will be announced on Monday morning.
We encourage you to share this contest on your Twitter or Facebook feed, especially if you're pulling for a certain restaurant.
Vote for your favorite place in the survey below and don't forget to click on the links below and rate the store on the Patch Place Listing. You can even leave a review.
Please let us know why you think your choice is the best. So without further ado, here are the places seeking your nominees!
Nanuet
- Pizza Amore
- Franco's Pizza
- Cacciatori Pizza
- Nonnas Pizza
- Martio's Ole Time Pizza
- Nanuet Restaurant
- Posa Posa Restaurant
- Nanuet Hotel & Restaurant
- Bella Luna Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pearl River
Tell Morris Maybrunch and Mary Kennedy I said hello.
People have way too much time on their hands to say mean things. Yes, their newcomers however, go just once and see what everyone is buzzing about!
But, older doesn't mean better, and M&M really stepped up the competition. M&M (aka Marly and Matt) definitely have the best food, staff, and atmosphere. Their menu is unbeatable (and yes, having a qualified chef helps when you're talking about preparing any sort of food). I usually get either the BBQ chicken (which is very difficult to find when you're looking for good quality) or some variety of a grilled chicken wrap. Their wraps are great - when I'm looking for a healthy alternative, they always have the perfect thing. Plus, emailed coupons and great sales? I don't get that anywhere else. I've never had a bad experience there - not with food, staff, or cleanliness (which I sometimes notice at other places). All in all, if you haven't tried it yet (which I'm sure the naysayers haven't), I highly recommend it. Five stars, M&M!
Best thin crust would be the Hotel. Best NYC slice around here would be Martio's. I agree with the poster about Fordham, that place needs a face lift and attitude change. Fix the front door already!
I can only imagine how sad the lives are of the adults that take the time to sit and come up with negativity towards another pizza shop. You guys honestly have nothing better to do with your lives? sad. I have never met Matt and Marly, but I have tried their pizza and the pizza is what this "poll" is about. Please don't be like an immature mean girl sitting on your computer all day. Be productive and move on.
Oh and by the way, I noticed this is also your first post. Welcome to the Patch.
You can get any topping and they taste great and they know how do do a "crispy" and "extra crispy" and "well done" to your requested perfection! You cant get that anywhere else.