CSEA Opposes LDC for Summit Park

Rockland CSEA urges legislator to vote against LDC describing it as “legal scheme”


The CSEA, New York State’s leading union, issued a statement Monday urging Rockland County legislators to reject the proposed Local Development Corporation (LDC). Rockland County Executive C. Scott Vanderhoef proposed transferring the county’s Summit Park nursing home to the LDC. The CSEA’s statement depicted the LDC as a “legal scheme” and “a non-regulated shell corporation that has little oversight and no accountability to taxpayers.”

CSEA Local 844 represents nursing home workers at Summit Park. The state union says it has publicly argued against LDCs questioning their legality and that they “should not be used to allow municipalities to skirt regulations or avoid public scrutiny.”

Summit Park Hospital and Nursing Care Center serves as the county’s public nursing home and long-term acute care hospital. A public hearing on the LDC proposal takes place Tuesday at 7:05 p.m.

In recent weeks, CSEA has undertaken a campaign to alert residents to the LDC proposal and encourage them to contact their legislator and attend the public hearing.

“The people we’ve spoken with are appalled by the county executive’s plan,” said CSEA Southern Region President Billy Riccaldo. “Residents don’t want Rockland County abandoning our seniors, especially through a scheme with such little transparency and accountability. It’s wrong to fast track the abandonment of the county’s moral responsibility to the senior population. Furthermore, the questionable legality of this process alone should raise serious questions.” 

CSEA has lawsuits pending in Onondaga and Saratoga counties related to those counties transferring their nursing homes to newly-created LDCs. The CSEA is arguing that a provision of the law states a local government cannot sell property for which there is still a necessary public purpose. CSEA said among the legal issues in question are accountability since taxpayers still retain debt obligations. 

The use of LDCs for such purposes has drawn scrutiny and criticism elsewhere. In an April 2011 report, State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli proposed reforms limiting local governments’ use of LDCs. The DiNapoli report criticized the use of LDCs to fund government operations. The CSEA noted the Center for Governmental Research, the Rochester-based think tank that performed a feasibility study on Summit Park, raised numerous concerns in a May 2011 report on LDCs including that they are not required to use competitive bidding and are not required to comply with the Open Meetings Law and Freedom of Information Laws.


Mike Hirsch April 15, 2013 at 04:50 PM
The county has two choices, an LDC or bankruptcy. Which choice does the CSEA prefer?
Andrew Wiley April 15, 2013 at 05:38 PM
In the event that the county uses the LDC to transfer county owned property the taxpayers will still be on the hook. The private concern that wins the bid will take any and all POTENTIAL profits and if they fail the taxpayers will get the property back with all the problems and more debt. This will not work and the taxpayer,workers and patients will all be negatively impacted. Fix the problem don't sell the asset it is not the problem.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »