Judges, Claiming 'Abdication' by Legislature, Back Court-Drawn Congressional Maps

Among the big changes: Lowey will pick up all of Rockland, Engel will not be representing Rockland and Hayworth will represent all of Orange County, while losing northern Rockland County.


Congressional districts in our region will look very different, after a panel of federal judges decided to approve a series of maps drawn by a magistrate colleague due to the lack of a redistricting agreement among state legislators.

The response from the district court judges, Reena Raggi, Gerard Lynch and Dora Irizarry, was a scolding to state lawmakers who failed to exercise their traditional role in redistricting for Congressional seats.

They wrote, "In the face of an outdated congressional districting plan, the application of which would plainly violate the requirements of federal law, and of the New York legislature’s complete abdication of its congressional redistricting duty, this court is obliged not only to recognize a violation of law but also to create a new redistricting plan to ensure against the disenfranchisement of state voters in the 2012 congressional elections."

The panel chose to adopt maps drawn by federal Magistrate Judge Roanne Mann, which were released March 12, with slight alterations to districts in New York City and upstate.

Locally, the adopted maps show that Rep. Nita Lowey (D-Harrison) will pick up all of Rockland County. The district, numbered as the 18th, will become known as the 17th. She will also pick up Mount Kisco and retain most of New Castle. However, she will lose its northern panhandle to Hayworth. This section of town falls entirely under the Mount Kisco postal zone and is near the New Croton Reservior. Overall, Lowey's district will shirt further north, as she will loses part of her sound shore constituents while seeing a district go up to Yorktown, Cortland and Peekskill.

"The newly-formed 17th Congressional District will include areas of Rockland County and northern Westchester that I have not previously represented. I am eager to introduce myself to community leaders and residents throughout the district, share my record of accomplishment for our community, and earn your vote," she said in a press release.

Lowey also announced her re-election bid today and weighed in on the change.

"The economy is showing signs of renewed strength, but too many Americans and communities are still struggling.  We must do more to create jobs and facilitate economic growth through smart investments, support for small businesses, and targeted relief for hard-pressed taxpayers," she said. "I am proud of my record of helping local businesses grow, fighting to ensure first responders receive the training and equipment they need to keep our community safe, supporting high-quality health care and education, and protecting our environment.  Perhaps most importantly, I have sought to help thousands of Hudson Valley residents - including senior citizens, students, veterans, and businesses - with problems large and small."

Elsewhere in the Hudson Valley, Eliot Engel (D-Bronx), will see a big change to his district. Engel currently represents a district that includes the northwestern part of the Bronx, traveling north up Yonkers, the Rivertowns and part of Tarrytown, and is connected to southern Rockland by the Tappan Zee Bridge. Now, his district will become geographically compact, remaining in the Bronx while picking up part of Lowey's southern Westchester area. His district will be renumbered from the 17th to the 16th.

Rep. Nan Hayworth (R-Bedford) will overall include much less of northern Westchester, while maintaining all of Putnam County, southern Dutchess County and now all of Orange County. She will, however, lose northern Rockland County.

Hayworth's district is much like her old one, except it has shifted northward. Notably, she loses the Village/Town of Mount Kisco, a community that has been part of her personal and social life, dating back to when she was a practicing ophamologist at the Mount Kisco Medical Group. Her husband Scott is its CEO. The district, currently known as the 19th, will be renumbered as the 18th. New York state's Congressional delegation will shrink from 29 to 27 seats because its growth was not strong in relation to other state, according to the 2010 Census. Redistricting is done every decade to account for population changes.

The new maps are being imposed in order for districts to be set in time for the state's Congressional elections.

A copy of the district judges' decision and order is attached here as a PDF file. To learn more about the court's role, click here for its docket sheet.

Mike Hirsch March 20, 2012 at 12:41 AM
This is very good for Rockland County. Now we will all be able to vote for the same representative. I'm glad that the judges stepped in and took it away from the politicians who only serve themselves. I am supporting Mark Rosen's candidacy. He is a West Point graduate, has served in Afghanistan, and is now working in the private sector. He is a new breed of politician who will fight for term limits in Washington, as well as being a fresh new voice for Democrats, Republicans, and Independents. Nita Lowey has never put the welfare of the people ahead of her own career. It's time for a change.
Rob McGunn March 20, 2012 at 02:20 AM
This is terrible for Rockland. I can't think of one time Nita Lowey has been to Rockland since part of Rockland became part of her district. Engel was at least available and accessible to his constituents. Expect more of Rockland getting Westchesters crumbs
Watchdog March 20, 2012 at 02:52 AM
WE can vote her out but FAT CHANCE of that happening since the UNIONS AND THE BLOC HASID VOTE Will overwhelm the rest of us. WE ARE DOOMED.
Watchdog March 20, 2012 at 02:53 AM
We don't Needa Lowey.
William Demarest (Editor) March 20, 2012 at 09:50 AM
Nita Lowey is a fairly regular visitor to Rockland County. However, her district has basically been limited to New City and Congers until this proposal.
William Demarest (Editor) March 20, 2012 at 09:52 AM
The last time Rockland County was in one Congressional District was when Ben Gilman was the congressman.
Mike March 20, 2012 at 11:03 AM
Mr. Dearest is correct, but what he fails to note is that the CD that was Rockland County also included parts of Orange County. This makes much more sense than this ridiculous plan that stretches our CD across a natural boundary like the Hudson River. Rockland simply should not be included Ina CD with Westchester. Now the new district is an improvement when the Dem controlled crooks who run Alabany had us in a district including the Bronx! However, it makes more sense to include RC with Orange since the economic, social, and demographics are much more similar than what we have with WC. Just another sign that this country is broke both economically and morally. Nita Lowey, btw, is as liberal as the do nothing engel. There will be no help for the hard working tax payers of RC.
Diane Hoch March 20, 2012 at 11:34 AM
Nita Lowey is a caring and concerned leader. As an advocate for children and Better School Food, Ms. Lowey campaigned for the welfare of our children by assisting in the raising of awareness - attending conferences and meetings (School's Open - Do you know what your children are eating?" - Planned Parenthood forums, etc...) showing support even when it crossed the lines of her "part of Rockland". I had met with Mr. Engel's office numerous times and heard nothing back .... I was quite offended as a taxpayer and concerned parent at the lack of regard for my voice and hard work. I welcome Nita Lowey and look forward to seeing her step into the job in which she is well suited!!
thomas gerondel March 20, 2012 at 12:13 PM
I think the biggest thing about losing Engel is I will miss him chaining himself to an aisle seat so he could be seen on TV with the president .TomGerondel
Mike Hirsch March 20, 2012 at 12:37 PM
Very true.
Mike Hirsch March 20, 2012 at 12:38 PM
Nita Lowey is just as useless as Engel.
Watchdog March 20, 2012 at 01:00 PM
He will still do that.
Watchdog March 20, 2012 at 01:06 PM
Typical liberal clap trap. Schools are a local issue LOWey should keep her hands off our schools and stop telling parents what to feed their kids. Don't get me started with PP.
Faith Fusillo March 20, 2012 at 02:24 PM
It is disgracefulul that the State Legislature could not, and did not, do its job, to the extent that a panel of Federal Judges had to step in and update the Congressional maps. What an embarrassment! We ask, and frankly, expect our children to play nicely; why is it that our elected officials cannot behave similarly? THIS is what is broken in our country, on every level: the ability of adults to do their jobs for the good of all, not their particular minions. That said, I am extremely happy to learn that Nita Lowey will be representing my interests in Rockland County. I have extensive experience with Ms. Lowey and her office, as she has represented -- and fought for -- my mother in Westchester County for several years. NOT ONE of our calls have gone unanswered or problems, whether large or small, kicked to the curb. Nita Lowey is a woman who gets things done -- which is more than I can say for our State Legislators, at least in this re-zoning task. Was it really that difficult boys and girls? Yeesh!!!
Watchdog March 20, 2012 at 02:51 PM
We need new blood. Time for these aging career politicians to step aside. They are part of the problem we will have gas prices of $5 a gallon very soon.
Mike Hirsch March 21, 2012 at 01:50 AM
I have just learned that Mark Rosen has been redistricted into Eliot Engel's Bronx district. They drew the line a few blocks away from his house. I guess the judges aren't immune to playing politics either. I think that Rockland actually comprises about 45% of Lowey's new district, so we will have a voice. Also for the first time, the number of republicans, independents, and no party voters outnumber the number of democrats in her district, so it is possible to defeat her.
Pat March 21, 2012 at 03:21 AM
I bet Lowey is already practicing her yiddish.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something