South Nyack Leaders, Residents Blast New Tappan Zee Bridge Plan

Constructing the new Hudson span would likely commandeer land from village residents

"We're right in the middle of a war zone, and I don't even have a gun," says Andrea Composto.

Composto is one of several South Nyackers who learned Tuesday that she will likely be directly affected by the construction of a new Tappan Zee Bridge. Transportation officials released a comprehensive document earlier this week outlining what lands may be commandeered for the project—and in the case of Composto, it is all of her neighbors' homes.

"They're taking all the houses around me, but not mine," she explained. Composto lives at and owns 79 Smith Avenue with her partner, Beth Brown. She purchased the home four years ago, and heard little from the state until now.

"About four years ago, we received a notice that our house was flagged," Composto said, adding the notification was not correct—it was meant for her neighbor. Composto straightened out the mix-up, she said.

Communication soon ceased; months passed without news, and then years.

But yesterday, she saw the aerial shot that was released—it shades in the properties that could tentatively be swept up by the project. And Composto's house is surrounded by shaded grids. Houses in front of and behind her are slated to be eaten up, as is a nearby green space.

"It's so disconcerting," she said. "Looking at this [aerial shot] boggles my mind. How do they think they can't notify me or compensate me or at the very least have a conversation with me?"

Composto says it is now time to become the squeaky wheel, and create a paper trail of objections.

"This hit me like a ton of bricks," she said. "I'm writing a letter to [transportation officials], and will get on the phone to my local representatives, too."

As for of the DEIS document—"It's already in my calendar," Composto said.

South Nyack officials are behind Composto completely.

"It's 1955 all over again," wrote mayor Trish DuBow in a Wednesday evening press release. "Once again, the state is steamrolling South Nyack."

DuBow hearkened back to the 1950s and construction of the original bridge, when broad swaths of South Nyack were wiped off the map.

"Now, 57 years later, in order to replace the bridge, they plan to take several more homes from South Nyack citizens," she said. "And for this sacrifice South Nyack gets nothing in return."

DuBow continued, calling the project "outrageous" and "unconscionable," and stated that South Nyack residents "deserve better."

DuBow said she and other village lawmakers met with state officials Wednesday night, securing a pledge from bridge project team members that the state will look into alternatives to perhaps spare some South Nyack infrastructure.

"The Village of South Nyack is committed to doing everything in its power to not only mitigate the impacts of this Tappan Zee Bridge replacement project on the village and protect its citizens, but to use the opportunity to gain some benefits for the River Villages region," DuBow added.

Politicians on a larger scale have been less involved with the details. Congressman Eliot Engel has voiced support for the project as a whole, but did not sound off on residents who may be affected.

"To my understanding they haven't asked us for help yet," said Joe O'Brien, Engel's press secretary.

Patch is awaiting a call back from the office of Joan McDonald, commissioner of the New York State Department of Transportation. In past interviews, McDonald said, "we have been planning and talking for too long—it's time to build a new Tappan Zee Bridge."

Watchdog January 29, 2012 at 01:56 AM
Ruby, In a lot of ways Government is unfair and some people seem to be OK with it as long as it does not affect them. When it does, the hue and outcry begins. Personally I am sympathetic to your situation and perhaps you should be compensated.
Ruby Frae January 29, 2012 at 02:27 PM
Watchdog, I am not OK with unfair Government whether it affects me or not. but its seems you just can't fight them no matter how much you cry Thanks for the sympathy..I guess it's just another hurdle in life.
elizabeth February 28, 2012 at 01:08 PM
This has nothing to do with "liberal vs conservative" politics! This project is not at all sensible, nor sensitive to the quality of life for village residents. My husband is a staunch Republican, and he is also an experienced engineer. He is adamently against the construction of the new bridge, without mass transit. He believes that repairing the existing bridge is a much more feasible option, if mass transit will not be added to a new one. By the way, he watches Fox!
Scott Walters February 28, 2012 at 01:51 PM
I lived for many years at a house on South Broadway where my parents still reside. I had wondered for many years about what would happen if an expansion or new construction ws going to happen. Bottom line is that we all know there needs to be a new bridge. What that new bridge may include is anyone's guess. If you have porperty near that area, you should have known that this was going to be the case. There was opportunity before the housing bubble burst for you to have sold your home. You didn't do this. If the home is bought by eminent domain, you may not get par value. The only person you need to be blaming is the person in the mirror. Sorry if I sound harsh or blunt, but I don't think what I have said is untrue.
John Gromada February 28, 2012 at 03:03 PM
Actually- the first assumption that you have wrong is that there needs to be a new bridge. This has become conventional 'wisdom' that just isn't true. Just read the DEIS to understand this. The bridge is not structurally deficient- just 'functionally obosolete'. One could say the same thing about any bridge in the region- and all are older than the TZ.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »